I know! I know! You are sick of food prompts. You are also sick of ice cream prompts.
But it's creamsicle day! Let's embrace it.
You can approach the prompt in several ways. You can photograph an actual creamsicle (or your favorite ice cream). Or... You can look for things that are different on the inside than they are on the outside. A creamsicle is orangey goodness on the outside, but yummy and creamy vanilla on the inside.
What can you photograph that is a surprise? An egg that has a hard exterior and soft interior? A seashell... that still has a critter living in it? My example photo is a shaved ice... that has ice cream stuffed in the middle! YUM!
Get the idea?